Hardly anyone is happy about the events of the past few weeks. To be sure, there are a few dubious winners. Those for whom predictions of economic doomsday is a hobby have had the satisfaction of saying "I told you so". Meantime, the executives at Goldman Sachs and other financial firms are reaping the tasty harvest of their well bought Congressmen.
For the majority of us — who find plenty to enjoy in the misery that actually visits us without savoring the anticipation of future misery — the economic crisis and the financial bailout have a tough time.
In real estate, our own fears for our future business are compounded by the fact that we know that other’s fears about their future can be a self fulfilling prophecy. People who are afraid cut back on their spending, and for most of us the largest share of our budget is housing.
A symptom of the overall terror is that a lot of my friends in the industry are looking to the security of other part time or full time jobs, with varying degrees of success.
What Happened When The News Broke?
As Congress was using the time honored mugger technique – threatening you with great harm that handing over your money will forestall — anecdotally it seemed like the sky fell. The phones just stopped ringing for about a week or two, and email inquiries trickled off to just about nothing.
That was pretty scary, though fortunately we’re starting to see people starting to look at homes again.
Even though on the face of it we thought our business destroyed, the weird thing about the awful news of the last few weeks is that it’s hard to prove (in a numerical way) how much of an impact this bad news really had. Sales this month have continued strong. With 1,369 sales in Sacramento County to date in October, we’re already 54.9% of the total volume for October of 2007, and although divining month end numbers is more of an art than a science, we’re looking at probably 1,600 to 2,200 sales for the month, with 2,020 being my best guess. This is in line with what we’ve been seeing in the last several months.
What About the Immediate Future? The Story of Sac County Pending Sales
Of course, the real story is in the pending sale numbers, since these tell the tale of homes going into escrow since the crisis. Here again, it’s hard to find a pattern that shows people are so scared that they’ve stopped buying homes altogether.
There are about 4005 homes that are pending sale (in escrow) in the MLS in Sacramento County. Absent an economic disaster, the pattern we expect to see is that the more recently you look, the greater the relative percentage of pending sales you’ll see. This is because as time goes on, those pending sales either fall out of escrow or close escrow.
In the presence of an economic disaster, you’d expect to find this pattern violated, but we really don’t. Of the 4,005 pending sales in Sac County, 2,013 went pending since October 1. As I write this on October 25th, 597 homes have gone pending in the last 5 days (since the 20th), and 1318 have gone pending in the last two fifteen days. Assuming 50% of all pending sales in the last fifteen days would close escrow (I think the actual numbers are higher but I don’t have the real "average close rate" to use), we’d be looking at about 1,318 sales for November — better volume numbers for November, 2008 than November, 2004’s 1,094 sales and almost as good as November, 2005’s figure of 1,446 sales.
Sure, that’s not as good as recent months, but it’s still much better than last November’s pathetic total of 809 sales. And in general, we’d expect it to be down somewhat from August through October, because sales almost always trend downward in November and December. And to be sure, those November numbers are projections — not real numbers.
Price (Not Consumer Confidence) Is King
If Elvis is "The King" in rock and roll terms, traditional wisdom in real estate is that price is king. What we’re seeing at least so far in October is that this is true even in a down market (assuming of course that a lack of credit is a mugger’s ploy and not a reality). With mortgage rates down since August and prices continuing to fall, on one level we’re all running from our own shadows, but meantime, back in the real world, the buyers are still out there — at least for now.
With that I’m sure someone will accuse me of being unduly optimistic — again! — which actually is a funny position to find oneself in given my systemic pessimism. Shhh… don’t give away my secret.
Related links:
How Have the Credit Crisis and Bailout Affected The Real Estate BusinessSacramento County Real Estate — Sold Prices and Unit Volume ChartsSacramento County Real Estate Market Review :: September, 2008